
The San Francisco Chronicle/SFGate must be desperate, based on their willingness to let Mike Boehm write about Genesis’ recent induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and what it might mean for the genre of prog rock at large.
Not that I’m complaining! I was pleasantly surprised by the piece, but being the narcissist I am (and not having been turned to a flower), I have a couple of thoughts …
After soldiering on proggishly but not that successfully for a couple of albums after Gabriel’s departure in 1975, the remaining members cannily transmogrified (uncanny transmogrification having been a core theme of the band’s earlier music) into a cuddlesome, MTV-ready trio led by that endearing, nonthreatening chap Phil Collins.
To characterize Genesis as middling immediately following Peter Gabriel’s departure works great as a dramatic device, but it’s simply not true. Despite being completely dismissed by the press at the time, the band came out with a great record, “Trick of the Tail,” which was not only their most well-produced work to date, but an enduring fan favorite to this day. This was followed by the biggest shows in America of the band’s career.
Also, Gabriel left in 1975, nine years before there was the chance to BE “ready for MTV.” During that time, the band’s shift in sensibilities was far more subtle than is implied here. “Duke,” the record from which “Misunderstanding” is taken, centered around a proggy song cycle that is among their most ambitious work. Even “Invisible Touch” contained the epic “Domino.” So yay for oversimplification.
I get what Boehm is saying about Tull, though. “Thick as a Brick” may be a crowing achievement (and scathing indictment) in the world of prog, but that doesn’t make them a prog band any more than earning a Grammy for Heavy Metal performance in 1989 made them hair metal.
Oh, ELP. Unless you are just shamelessly devoted to prog, it’s hard to not have a love/hate relationship with them. I love “Brain Salad Surgery,” but I think I’d rather hear Jerry Lee Lewis interpret “Six Gnossiennes” than “Tarkus.”
Once during a road trip with some friends I was listening to “Tarkus” on satellite radio when my friend Charin leaned in from the back and simply said “This is the worst music I have ever heard.” I could crashed the car from laughing so hard.
I know why I love prog rock. But I also know why so many hate it. I’ll say this – when estimating “Tales from Topographic Oceans,” it’s better when you stare at the album art. On a REAL album.
I’m kind of disappointed Boehm has dismissed Kansas as an American prog rock band. He should know better, since I know plenty of people whose thoughts of Genesis go no further than “Tonight Tonight Tonight,” and associating Kansas only with their FM staple hits is just as myopic.
But moreover, what about our favorite tuque-wearing trio … RUSH?
